The Buffalo Bills went into trade deadline week needing a safety, and on Monday morning they watched an AFC rival take the best one off the board. Jacksonville’s deal for Jessie Bates landed hours before Buffalo’s Monday night game in Minnesota, and ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler reported soon after that the Bills “have scanned the safety pool of late.”
That makes a Bills safety trade one of the storylines to watch before Tuesday’s 4 p.m. ET deadline. The need is real. The money is tight. And the list of realistic options is shorter than it was on Sunday.
Why Buffalo is shopping for a safety
The hole opened on Nov. 3, when the Bills released C.J. Gardner-Johnson a day after he finished a one-game NFL suspension for spitting in the direction of Las Vegas Raiders players, the AP reported. Gardner-Johnson had signed a one-year deal worth up to $6 million in March to start next to Cole Bishop, and he started all six games he played for Buffalo.
Without him, the back end looks thin for a 6-1 team with Super Bowl hopes. Athlon Sports pointed out that through seven games, the entire Bills defense had four interceptions. A single Titans safety has five.
General manager Brandon Beane hasn’t hidden his plans. He told the AP’s John Wawrow last week that he’s as aggressive as ever heading into the deadline and is most likely targeting defense. SI’s Albert Breer and The Athletic’s Jonathan Jones have both reported that Buffalo is looking at defensive help, with a safety or cornerback the most likely target.
The cap problem
Here’s the catch. Buffalo has under $4 million in cap space, about $3.93 million according to Over the Cap figures cited by Athlon. That rules out a lot of players unless the selling team agrees to keep part of the salary, or the Bills send a contract back the other way.
Jacksonville showed how that works. Atlanta paid most of the $6.5 million left on Bates’ salary to get the deal done, as we covered in our Jessie Bates trade breakdown. Any team selling to the Bills would likely have to do something similar.
Amani Hooker: the best fit
If there’s one name that keeps coming up, it’s Tennessee’s Amani Hooker.
The 28-year-old leads the NFL with five interceptions, including three against Joe Burrow in Week 8, according to CBS Sports. Bleacher Report noted he also has 114 interception-return yards and has allowed a passer rating of just 60.2 in coverage. The Titans are 1-7 and rebuilding.
He isn’t a rental, either. Hooker is signed through 2028, which means he could solve the position for more than this season. The Ringer named Buffalo as a possible destination and estimated his value at around a third-round pick.
The problems are money and willingness. Spotrac estimates Hooker has about $4.4 million left in 2026 compensation, a bit more than Buffalo’s cap room, and his cap hit rises to about $13.2 million in 2027. Tennessee has also signaled it isn’t eager to sell. ESPN’s Turron Davenport reported that general manager Mike Borgonzi isn’t planning more deals after the Jeffery Simmons trade unless he gets an offer he can’t refuse.
Budda Baker: the big name
Arizona’s Budda Baker is the most accomplished option. He’s an eight-time Pro Bowler, and at 30, he’s still productive, with 51 tackles, 3.5 sacks and an interception through eight games, per Bleacher Report.
His stance may be shifting. Earlier this season, Baker told ESPN’s Josh Weinfuss he wanted to stay in Arizona. On Monday, Fowler reported Baker would “welcome the chance” to join a contender if the Cardinals were willing to move him, according to Pro Football Rumors. The Cardinals are 3-6.
There’s a Buffalo connection too. Bills receivers coach Drew Terrell and special teams coordinator Jeff Rodgers both spent multiple seasons in Arizona with Baker, Buffalo Rumblings noted.
The contract is the hurdle. Spotrac estimates about $7.3 million left on his 2026 pay, nearly double Buffalo’s space, plus a non-guaranteed $17.8 million in 2027. Pro Football Rumors added that because Baker is under contract for next year, Arizona would likely ask for more than the Falcons got for Bates.
The cheaper options
If the bigger deals don’t come together, the Bills could look at lower-cost players. NFL insider Vic Carucci named Washington safety Nick Cross, a 25-year-old in his first season with the Commanders, as a possible target. Bills On SI has also listed Jeremy Chinn, Elijah Molden and Isaiah Pola-Mao among cap-friendly names.
None of those players would change the defense the way Hooker or Baker could. But for a team with so little room, a smaller move might be the only one that fits.
Bills safety trade options at a glance
| Player | Team | Age | 2026 production | Contract note | Biggest obstacle |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amani Hooker | Titans | 28 | NFL-high 5 INTs | Signed through 2028 | Titans reluctant; about $4.4M left in 2026 |
| Budda Baker | Cardinals | 30 | 51 tackles, 3.5 sacks, 1 INT | $17.8M non-guaranteed in 2027 | About $7.3M left in 2026; high asking price |
| Nick Cross | Commanders | 25 | Played in 4 games | Younger, cheaper option | Smaller impact |
Contract figures via Spotrac; stats via Bleacher Report and CBS Sports.
How the Vikings game fits in
The timing is awkward. Buffalo plays in Minneapolis at 8:15 p.m. ET Monday, which leaves less than a day after the final whistle to finish any deal. Teams sometimes wait to see the injury report from a game like this before deciding how aggressive to be.
It also matters who’s covering the deep middle on Monday night. Minnesota has one of the league’s best defenses but is starting backup quarterback Carson Wentz, as we noted in our Bills vs Vikings preview. If Buffalo’s secondary holds up, Beane might feel less urgency. If it doesn’t, the phone lines to Nashville and Phoenix could get busy.
Beane’s track record says something is coming
Buffalo has been a buyer at past deadlines, and Beane’s comments this year point the same way. The Bills already watched the Jaguars, one of their main rivals for the AFC’s top seed, add an All-Pro safety. Standing still would mean heading into the second half with a starter’s spot still unsettled next to Cole Bishop.
The most likely outcome is a deal that needs some creativity: a seller keeping salary, a late-round pick moving, maybe a player going back the other way. Whether it’s Hooker, Baker or a cheaper name, Tuesday afternoon should tell us how serious Buffalo is about January.
Our NFL trade deadline guide will track any Bills move as soon as it’s reported.
Join the conversation